Ranked No. 1 for slices in the 2026 50 Top Pizza USA list and No. 1 on Time Out's NYC pizza li...
Best NYC Pizza Slices
This is a slice tour of New York City for pizza fans and first-time visitors, running from the Lower East Side, Greenwich Village and the Upper West Side to Brooklyn's Williamsburg, Greenpoint, Park Slope and Gravesend. Joe's Pizza on Carmine Street serves the benchmark thin, foldable slice. Scarr's Pizza mills its own grain for a sturdier crust, served in a wood-paneled room that feels pulled from the 1970s. At L'Industrie Pizzeria, the burrata slice is the order. Mama's TOO! is all about airy, crunchy-edged squares, and L&B Spumoni Gardens serves thick Sicilian squares with the sauce over the cheese, eaten at outdoor picnic tables with a cup of spumoni to finish.
L'Industrie draws a line on weekends, so a weekday afternoon is the easiest time to go.
Sign in to followLoading map…
Ranked No. 4 for slices in the 2026 50 Top Pizza USA list and a Time Out top-three pick. The a...
Scarr's mills grain in-house for a sturdier, flavorful crust, served in a wood-paneled room th...
Open since 1975, Joe's is the benchmark thin, foldable NYC slice and appears on nearly every b...
A Time Out top-20 pick with a 1970s pizzeria look, creative toppings and strong vegan options....
Ranked No. 6 for slices in the 2026 50 Top Pizza USA list. Slices use imported DOP ingredients...
Since 1939, L&B has served thick Sicilian squares with sauce over the cheese, eaten at outdoor...